Guilda Work or Excel: what to use to run an accounting firm
Excel is flexible and free, and to start it is enough. What changes as a firm grows is not the spreadsheet but what has to be typed, remembered and shared between people. Here is the comparison, task by task.
Excel is flexible, familiar and nearly free. To start, nothing more is needed. What changes as a firm grows is not the spreadsheet but what has to be typed, remembered and shared between several people.
Comparison, task by task
| Task | With Excel | With Guilda Work |
|---|---|---|
| Filing dates for each client | You type them or copy them from the calendar, client by client | They are generated from each client's tax profile, with a reminder before each date |
| Incoming invoices | Copied by hand from the invoice into a row | AI proposes the invoice data and a person reviews it before it is booked |
| Bank | Compared by eye or with formulas you have to maintain | Bank reconciliation proposes matches between transactions and invoices, which a person confirms |
| Asking clients for documents | By email, with the follow-up in another column | Requests in the client portal, with a deadline and reminders |
| Who did what | Depends on who edits each file | Every change is kept in a history with the person and the date |
| What each person sees | Whoever opens the file sees everything, unless you split one file per client | Each person sees the clients assigned to them |
When Excel is enough
- You are one person or a very small team.
- You have few clients and almost no incoming invoices.
- Clients do not need to upload anything: they already send you everything and it works.
In that case a well-ordered sheet is a reasonable tool and there is no hurry to change.
When it stops being enough
- The team grows and you need to split clients, know who handles what and who touched what.
- The invoice volume grows and typing them eats the hours of the quarter.
- A deadline cannot fail and you do not want to depend on someone remembering to look at a column.
- Clients are slow to send what is missing and your follow-up lives in email.
Moving on from Excel without starting from scratch
You import your client list from Excel or CSV, and whatever you still want to analyse in Excel exports back (for example a client's VAT book). You do not have to stop using Excel: it just stops being the place where the work lives.
What a person still does
Review what the AI proposes, decide and file. Guilda Work removes typing and chasing, not professional responsibility.
Frequently asked questions
Can I import my clients from Excel?
Yes. They are imported from an Excel (.xlsx) or CSV file with the column names in the first row.
Can I keep getting data out to Excel?
Yes. For example, a client's VAT book exports to Excel or CSV, so you are not locked in.
Is it worth switching if I work alone with few clients?
Maybe not yet. If you are one person with few clients and almost no incoming invoices, a good spreadsheet may be enough. The change shows when the team, the invoice volume or the risk of missing a deadline grows.